[2021] NewSim Feedback

Nittany Boiler

Coordinator
SEC
LV
0
 
Posts
65
Karma
71
Issues: MIZZ vs. VANDY

Incorrect Penalty
15:20VAND3729 VANDPassQB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for WR Drew Bryan. PENALTY: Neutral Zone Infraction OLB J.P. Bracy
15:13VAND31034 VANDRunRB Justin Cooks carries for 2 yards. Tackled by DT Brian Ford.

Incorrect Interception / Change of Possession
14:12MIZZ11049 VANDPassQB Aaron Leamon intercepted by FS Josh Westerman returned for 0 yards from the LOS. intended for FB Lucas Walford.
14:2MIZZ21049 VANDPassQB Aaron Leamon complete to WR Owa Guzman for 6 yards. Tackled by SS Mason Hauschild.

Incorrect Penalty
214:50VAND11047 MIZZPassQB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for WR Drew Bryan. PENALTY: Offensive Holding C T.J. Fernandez
214:30VAND11047 MIZZPassQB Gehrig Crecelius complete to WR Ifeadi Adams for 19 yards. Tackled by OLB J.P. Bracy.

Yardage on Interception?
27:47VAND3823 VANDPassQB Gehrig Crecelius intercepted by FS Aristides Jackson returned for 67 yards from the LOS. intended for WR Drew Bryan.
27:27MIZZ11010 MIZZPassQB Aaron Leamon incomplete. Thrown Away.

Incorrect Penalty
35:33MIZZ2933 MIZZRunRB Vyncint Brooks carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DE Geoff Lakins. PENALTY: False Start OG Luke Gillislee
35:20MIZZ21028 MIZZPassQB Aaron Leamon incomplete. Thrown Away.

Incorrect Change of Possession
42:28MIZZ11025 MIZZRunRB Vyncint Brooks carries for -2 yards. Ran out of bounds.
42:7VAND11023 MIZZPassQB Gehrig Crecelius incomplete. Intended for RB Justin Cooks.

*** Changed the game - Vanderbilt scored immediately and pulled within 6 points

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seven Interceptions in one game after 2 interceptions in the first 9 games???????
 

rcarlson77

Coordinator
Big 12
LV
0
 
Posts
60
Karma
71
Should have been a safety?

24:49WVU11016 WVUPassQB Logan Gabriel is sacked by DE Arden Ware for -7 yards. .
24:37WVU2179 WVUPassQB Logan Gabriel is sacked by DE Arden Ware and DT Liam Finney for -15 yards. .
24:26WVU332-6 WVUPassQB Logan Gabriel incomplete. Intended for FB Patrick Nuno.
24:14WVU432-6 WVUPuntP Brent Martin punts for 46 yards. RB Fernando Gonzalez returns the ball 14 yards. Tackled by RB Austin Brady.
24:2TTU11026 WVUPassQB Jordan Madero complete to WR Nick Wake for 19 yards. Tackled by FS DaQuan Watson.
23:41TTU177 WVURunRB Fernando Gonzalez carries for 7 yards. TOUCHDOWN!
 

kgreene829

Head Coach
AAC
LV
0
 
Posts
151
Karma
150
The balls on this kicker to try and make a field goal from around the world.
14:23NEV4737 USAFField GoalK Dorren Peraza's -11 yard field goal attempt is no good.

This happened a couple of times just looks like it is forgetting to add a 0 for the time
47:12NEV4826 NEVPuntP Travis Gonzalez punts for 36 yards. CB Nick Houser returns the ball 12 yards. Ran out of bounds.
47:0USAF11050RunQB Anthony Sweeney carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DE Andre Brown.
46:18USAF2949 NEVPassQB Anthony Sweeney complete to RB Malcolm Jernigan for 4 yards. Tackled by CB DaeSean Thompson.

43:47NEV31020 NEVRunQB Nelson Holland carries for -2 yards. Tackled by DE Julian Thomas.
43:9NEV41218 NEVPuntP Travis Gonzalez punts for 72 yards. WR Eric Steele returns the ball 14 yards. Ran out of bounds.
42:57USAF11024 USAFRunRB Malcolm Jernigan carries for 8 yards. Ran out of bounds.
 

Jmjacobs

Head Coach
PAC-12
LV
0
 
Posts
148
Karma
32
Awards
1
37:29UCLA1-5-5 CALRunQB Hiram Maronde carries for -5 yards. TOUCHDOWN!
 

Rocketcan

NewSim Dev
Big Ten
LV
0
 
Posts
2,394
Karma
1,146
Awards
4
SimBBA Career
UMBC
Can you post the last play before it was on a negative yard line and then any plays between that play and this one that you posted?

I hope that makes sense.
 

Jmjacobs

Head Coach
PAC-12
LV
0
 
Posts
148
Karma
32
Awards
1
38:44UCLA11035 UCLARunRB Dan Garcia carries for 1 yard. Tackled by DT Stephen McCalister.
38:7UCLA2936 UCLAPassQB Hiram Maronde complete to WR Jose Colabello for 38 yards. Tackled by ILB Morgan King.
37:48UCLA11026 CALPassQB Hiram Maronde complete to RB Dan Garcia for 16 yards. Tackled by CB Adam Ijalana. PENALTY: Defensive Pass Interference CB Breyvic Asiata
37:29UCLA1-5-5 CALRunQB Hiram Maronde carries for -5 yards. TOUCHDOWN!
37:12UCLAN/AN/A3 CALExtra PointK Andrew Trinnaman's extra point attempt is good.
 

ChizDippler

Coordinator
MWC
LV
0
 
Posts
67
Karma
52
1876

Here is a whole mess of bugs. yardage on the punt was way off. then penalty on TD....
 

subsequent

Website Admin
Big Ten
LV
0
 
Posts
1,271
Karma
1,091
Awards
3
SimBBA Career
UC Irvine
1921

Wisconsin had a Touchdown that also had a false start. Touchdown was not included in the QB's box score, but did count into the overall score, which should not have counted as it was an offensive penalty.

 

subsequent

Website Admin
Big Ten
LV
0
 
Posts
1,271
Karma
1,091
Awards
3
SimBBA Career
UC Irvine
Wishlist for stats:

Individual sacks allowed
Pancakes
D/ST TDs
Turnover yards (Int and Fumble Recovery yards)
Safeties
Punt yards (not present in the current stats sheets, but does appear in box score)
Passes defended

@tsweezy any more?
 
Last edited:

Sarge

Head Coach
SEC
LV
0
 
Posts
164
Karma
193
Drive data would be awesome. Just something in the stat sheet called "Drives" it were possible. It would help me flesh out some defensive metrics for teams.
 

subsequent

Website Admin
Big Ten
LV
0
 
Posts
1,271
Karma
1,091
Awards
3
SimBBA Career
UC Irvine
Ongoing stats feedback:
  • Linebacker (unsure for DL) total tackles may be low
    • Our top 20 - 68-87 tackles
    • 2019 IRL top ~20 - 114-149 tackles (one outlier at 181)
    • 2018 IRL top ~20 - 126-155 tackles (one outlier at 176)
    • 2017 IRL top ~20 - 117-153 tackles (one outlier at 173)
  • DE/DT tackles MAY be too high
    • I don't have great numbers to go through, but the NCAA stats website only shows around the top 500 players for tackles
      • Overall
        • Top 24 players (due to ties)
          • Solo tackles
            • Average of 57.67
            • High of 64 (two players)
            • Low of 55 (five players)
          • Assisted tackles
            • Average of 7.6
            • High of 11 (one player)
            • Low of 7 (13 players)
          • Total tackles
            • Average of 61.2
            • High of 66 (one player)
            • Low of 59 (five players)
      • 2019
        • 15 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
          • Solo tackles
            • Average of 34.13
            • High of 54 (one player)
            • Low of 18 (two players)
          • Assisted tackles
            • Average of 33.67
            • High of 46 (one player)
            • Low of 16 (one player)
          • Total tackles
            • Average of 67.8
            • High of 99 (one player)
            • Low of 54 (one player)
      • 2018
        • 28 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
          • Solo tackles
            • Average of 33.82
            • High of 74 (massive outlier as next is 47) (one player)
            • Low of 16 (one player)
          • Assisted tackles
            • Average of 33.04
            • High of 47 (one player)
            • Low of 18 (one player)
          • Total tackles
            • Average of 66.86
            • High of 118 (outlier as most are below 70) (one player)
            • Low of 56 (one player)
      • 2017
        • 26 players listed as DL in the top 500 players by # of tackles list
          • Solo tackles
            • Average of 34.15
            • High of 47 (two players)
            • Low of 10 (massive outlier as next is 24) (one player)
          • Assisted tackles
            • Average of 36.69
            • High of 66 (one player)
            • Low of 20 (one player)
          • Total tackles
            • Average of 70.85
            • High of 103 (one player)
            • Low of 55 (one player)
  • Deeper dive into tackles
    • Overall
      • For top 20 players by solo tackles
        • Average of 73.9
          • High of 87 (one player)
          • Low of 69 (one player)
      • For top 21 players by assisted tackles (due to ties)
        • Average of 8.76
          • High of 13 (one player)
          • Low of 8 (12 players)
      • For top 20 players by total tackles
        • Average of 77.7
          • High of 88 (one player)
          • Low of 73 (one player)
      • Note: the player with the most solo tackles only had one assisted tackle, so player with most solo tackles and most total tackles is same player
    • 2019 IRL
      • Top 24 players by solo tackles (due to ties)
        • Average of 71.42
          • High of 103 (one player)
          • Low of 66 (five players)
      • Top 20 players by assisted tackles
        • Average of 67.71
          • High of 86 (one player)
          • Low of 59 five players)
      • Top 20 players by total tackles
        • Average of 126.48
          • High of 181 (one player)
          • Low of 114 five players)
    • 2018 IRL
      • Top 20 players by solo tackles
        • Average of 78.91
          • High of 108 (one player)
          • Low of 71 (four players)
      • Top 20 players by assisted tackles
        • Average of 73.75
          • High of 90 (one player)
          • Low of 62 (two players)
      • Top 20 players by total tackles
        • Average of 140.05
          • High of 176 (one player)
          • Low of 127 (two players)
    • 2017 IRL
      • Top 21 players by solo tackles (due to ties)
        • Average of 78.48
          • High of 94 (one player)
          • Low of 69 (two players)
      • Top 21 players by assisted tackles (due to ties)
        • Average of 74.48
          • High of 96 (one player)
          • Low of 62 (two players)
      • Top 20 players by total tackles
        • Average of 135.55
          • High of 173 (one player)
          • Low of 120 (one player)
  • Field goal kicking needs a buff
    • Overall, FG% was 2103/3302 (~64%)
    • 2019 IRL - 75%
    • 2018 IRL - 74%
    • 2017 IRL - 73%
  • XP kicking needs a buff
    • Overall, XP% was 3041/3267 (~93%)
    • 2019 IRL - 97%
    • 2018 IRL - 97%
    • 2017 IRL - 97%
  • Sacks allowed may be too low
    • 6 teams with 5 sacks allowed, 9 teams with 4 sacks allowed, 5 teams with 3 sacks allowed, 6 teams with 2 sacks allowed, 3 teams with 1 sack allowed, 1 team with 0 sacks allowed
    • 2019 IRL - 1 team with 4 sacks allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 128 teams with 12 or more sacks allowed
    • 2018 IRL - 1 team with 3 sacks allowed, 1 team with 7 sacks allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 126 teams with 10 or more sacks allowed
    • 2017 IRL - 1 team with 1 sack allowed, 1 team with 8 sacks allowed, 127 teams with 10 or more sacks allowed
  • Individual sacks looks low as well
    • Overall, for top 28 players by sacks (due to ties)
      • Average of 6.82
        • High of 9 (one player)
        • Low of 6 (14 players)
    • 2019 IRL
      • Average of 12 (out of 22 due to ties)
        • High of 16.5 (one player)
        • Low of 9.5 (three players)
    • 2018 IRL
      • Average of 11 (out of 25 due to ties)
        • High of 17.5 (one player)
        • Low of 9.5 (seven players)
    • 2017 IRL
      • Average of 9.8 (out of 32 due to ties)
        • High of 14 (one player)
        • Low of 8.5 (13 players)
  • Overall, offenses (specifically PaYDs, PaYD/attempt) needs to be nerfed or passing defense needs to be buffed
    • Overall, for top 20 QB:
      • PaYDs: 4463.8
      • Comp: 325.55
      • Attempts: 506.85
      • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.91
      • Comp% (min. 100 attempts): 69.82%
      • TD: 32.15
      • INT: 17.15
    • 2019 IRL:
      • PaYDs 3904
      • Comp: 305.25
      • Attempts: 472.05
      • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.26
      • Comp%: 68.5%
      • TD: 33.65 (out of 23 players due to ties)
      • INT: 12.42 (out of 24 players due to ties)
    • 2018 IRL:
      • PaYDs: 3827.75
      • Comp: 301.7
      • Attempts: 466.35
      • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 9.11
      • Comp%: 67.76%
      • TD: 32.71 (out of 21 players due to ties)
      • INT: 12.82 (out of 22 players due to ties)
    • 2017 IRL:
      • PaYDs: 3947.25
      • Comp: 303.05
      • Attempts: 482.2
      • PaYD/Attempt (min. 100 attempts): 8.98
      • Comp%: 66.03%
      • TD: 32.7
      • INT: 13.29 (out of 24 players due to ties)
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Top